Qualitative Research - Critique

Qualitative Research - Critique

Assignment

Q.1. Has the writer identified a problem as the basis for this study? What is it? Is it clearly described?

Identifying a problem in qualitative research is based on exploration of the area in which research is to be conducted. In fact, problem formulation provides a depth of understanding as problem formulation uses general methodology and topic in order to investigate a specific problem (Sekaran & Bougie, 2010). As far as identification of problem in this article is concerned, it can be seen that authors identify the problem of practicing strategic planning and its association with the financial performance. However, it is also a fact that the subject of strategic planning is a broader area and requires a deeper insight through exploratory approach as the progress of strategic planning processes is difficult to measure through statistical information. No doubt, researcher attempted to address the problem in a scholarly manner and clearly explained their research problem. However, the data collection approach they used is based on survey, which can be found in most quantitative methods.

Q.2. Has the writer presented and defended the significance of this problem as the basis for the study?

The qualitative research suggests that explaining the problem or area of research interest develops comprehensive understanding as well as communicates thorough significance of that problem (Sekaran & Bougie, 2010). It is also a fact that researcher in qualitative research develops preliminary concepts that allow them to collect data as indicators in relation to defined founding concepts. In this article, it can be seen that researchers developed a strong foundation for their study and explained the significance of strategic planning in a particular context of healthcare organizations. They established well-designed propositions that include the importance of strategic planning process, positive impact of strategic planning process on financial ...