Probability Judgements And Jury Reasoning

Read Complete Research Material

PROBABILITY JUDGEMENTS AND JURY REASONING

What do probability judgements and jury reasoning tell us about the role of mental models in decision making?

What do probability judgements and jury reasoning tell us about the role of mental models in decision making?

It is rare that people wait for four or more occasions of lying before concluding that the person in question is a liar. We make a judgment on trustworthiness after we see a behavior pattern repeated only one to three times.

That is how quickly we make conclusions about a person's untrustworthiness. We are quick to judge untrustworthiness. Trust, on the other hand, takes longer to build. This means that for most people, they do not like to bear the (material) risk or cost of trusting someone whose future action shows he is not trustworthy. To them this cost is more important than the (goodwill) cost from not trusting someone when in fact he is trustworthy. Material costs seem to be more important to most people than goodwill costs.

In the American jury system, if only one juror in twelve entertains reasonable doubt, a man cannot be condemned for a criminal offense. In Scotland, there are fifteen jurors (thanks to Michael Heaney for pointing this out). The reason is that Western legal systems consider the cost (to the individual accused) of condemning an innocent person to be more important than the cost (to the rest of society) of not punishing a guilty person. In the Western mindset, an individual's rights are paramount.

In modern scientific practice, a conclusion is not accepted for publication if the probability that that conclusion is wrong is more than 5%. This is the “sacred p<.05" criteria among scientists. Scientists' criterion for acceptance is stricter than the jury system. To scientists, getting at the empirical truth is a more strict procedure ...
Related Ads
  • Jury System
    www.researchomatic.com...

    The Jury system is used by many countries of the wor ...

  • Summary Jury Trials
    www.researchomatic.com...

    Summary of the jury an alternative method of dispute ...

  • Commonsense Justice
    www.researchomatic.com...

    They supply the citizen on the road and the juror ...

  • O.J. Simpson Case Study
    www.researchomatic.com...

    Of course, there is furthermore the likelihood ...

  • Jury Bias
    www.researchomatic.com...

    Jury Bias, Jury Bias Essay writing help source. . ...